How Catholic Europe answered Machiavelli
When Machiavelli argued that a ruler could not build and keep a powerful state while holding to traditional Christian morality, he set off a debate over politics, ethics, and religion that ran through the culture of the Baroque. In the late sixteenth century, an international school of anti-Machiavellian writers closely tied to the Counter-Reformation took him on directly. They argued that a Christian prince could succeed in politics, and was in fact more likely to, and they set out in detail how a state could be kept and strengthened without giving up Christian ethics.
Robert Bireley offers the first major study of this tradition. He gives individual chapters to six of its essential figures: Giovanni Botero, Justus Lipsius, Pedro de Ribadeneira, Diego Saavedra Fajardo, Adam Contzen, and Carlo Scribani. Botero and Lipsius were perhaps the most widely read political writers of the early seventeenth century. Bireley places each writer in his historical setting. He follows their thinking on recurring questions: virtue, reputation, and power; the uses of deceit; economic development; war; religion and toleration; and the role of fortune and providence. He shows that their ideas shaped the world in which statesmen such as Maximilian of Bavaria, Cardinal Richelieu, and the count-duke of Olivares made their decisions. The result is essential reading for understanding the Counter-Reformation, Baroque political culture, and the long argument over whether good politics requires good people.