“A surprisingly easy read because Rable never assumes the reader already knows about army life.” — Washington Post
“Rable has written a new kind of battle history that melds many different types of history into one, all-inclusive narrative. Rable is one of the most versatile Civil War historians in the field today.” — Civil War History
“Skillfully done. . . . The pace of the story is fast . . . much like the battle itself. . . . One of the most interesting renditions of any battle.” — Civil War News
“A very balanced, readable, and thought-provoking account. . . . The author never loses sight of the common soldier — the evocative text is filled with first-person descriptions of life in the camp, on the march, in battle, or in field hospitals. It captures the bravery, ineptitude, and heartache of soldiers and generals alike.” — Blue & Gray Magazine
“Masterful . . . . By successfully synthesizing recent scholarship and plowing new ground as well, this book takes its place as the best volume published thus far in the Littlefield History of the Civil War Era.” — American Historical Review
“[This book] sets a new standard for Civil War historians who write about military campaigns. George C. Rable provides not just an account of a horrific battle, but how it changed the course of the war for both sides and the men who fought in its ranks.” — Civil War Book Review
“Rable’s recounting of the campaign deserves special notice, now more than ever, because it conveys much more than simply a tale of combat. . . . What Rable succeeds in doing, in spectacular fashion, is to offer us an intensely human account of a single campaign. . . . He has drawn upon the large literature on this subject and grounded it in a specific context. . . . The result is the most detailed study to date about a soldier’s experience grounded in a single battle.” — H-Civil War
“Exhaustively researched and very well written, Fredericksburg! Fredericksburg! is the definitive history of the battle. Buffs and scholars who may wish to discount Fredericksburg’s significance will have to acknowledge the strong arguments Rable presents. The book deserves to be in everyone’s Civil War library.” — Journal of American History
“An excellent book: extensively researched, clearly written, judiciously interpreted. From war front to home front, from newspaper office to the halls of Congress, Rable fuses the 'old' and 'new' military histories to relate more about what Fredericksburg meant than we have ever known before.” — Journal of Southern History
“Rable’s fine volume will be the standard study of Fredericksburg for a long time to come.” — Journal of Military History
