“Robertson’s command of the subject shines in his expert analysis of conflicting accounts by participants, and colorful anecdotes that illuminate what might otherwise seem mundane.”—Americas Civil War Magazine
“Offers a remarkable scope. . . . An authoritative analysis of how the rigors of campaigning affected command decisions and the experiences of common soldiers alike.”—Civil War Monitor
“This volume leaves no stone unturned. . . . Robertson makes every effort to include as many personal observations from soldiers and officers of both armies, providing what amounts to real-time situational awareness. . . . An excellent book which will leave readers eagerly anticipating the next volume and the culmination of the campaign.”—On Point
“The work is must reading for any student of the Chickamauga campaign. One awaits Volume 2 with great anticipation.”—Journal of Southern History
“Possibly the most exhaustively detailed description of the campaign, certainly of the pre-battle phase, ever to appear in print. The biographic sketches of the principal participants and their interactions are good; the frequent quotations from soldiers' letters, diaries and journals give color to the progress of the campaign. The overall description of events is excellent and easy to follow. . . . Robertson knows Chickamauga like few others and lays it all out here.”—Journal of Americas Military Past
“This magisterial volume on the war of movement leading up to the climactic Battle of Chickamauga will long remain the standard study of events in the Civil War’s western theater in summer 1863. . . . [Robertson’s] familiarity with his subject matter may well exceed that of the two principal commanders involved. . . . The resulting volume knits together the firsthand accounts of hundreds of participants in a comprehensive whole unrivalled in detail or complexity.”—Michigan War Studies Review
“There have been other accounts of the Chickamauga Campaign, but this book is in a class by itself. The wealth of information here is astonishing.”—Steven E. Woodworth, author of Shiloh
“Robertson’s long-anticipated work is certain to become the ”must read“ book on the Chickamauga campaign. Based on decades of research and fieldwork, it is the most thoroughly investigated study of the most dramatic campaign of the Western theater.”—Earl Hess, author of Fighting for Atlanta
