“Traces the shifting arguments made by the workers and the politicians who sought to transform an agency that was fiercely opposed to transformation.” — Kelefa Sanneh, The New Yorker
“Provides a relentless display of facts, figures, and insights in narrating this black labor resistance to intransigent white supremacy. He does so with an able collection of archival evidence, oral histories, and a survey of secondary literature, all told as a gripping story that includes some memorable individuals and concludes with a qualified upbeat ending—at least for now.”—American Historical Review
“It is this history of segregation, and of resistance to it, that Goldberg chronicles masterfully, from firehouse fistfights to fraternal organizations to federal litigation.”—Gotham Center for New York History
“Works hard to remind us, powerfully at times, about black firefighters' courage, persistent struggle against discrimination, and efforts to work the system for greater racial equity.”—Journal of American History
“A welcome contribution to literature on race and labor in American cities. . . . Goldberg reminds us how central public employment has been to the economic and political struggles of African Americans over the past century.”—Journal of African American History
“That we can know so much about Black firefighters in one locale—even during early years in which they constituted a literal handful of workers—is both a pleasant surprise and a tribute to the assiduous research of Goldberg in archives and in the mining of oral histories. The textured evidence, in terms of both policy decisions and personal experiences, is deeply impressive and persuasive. The characters that emerge here are compelling in a way all too rare in labor history.”—David Roediger, author of Seizing Freedom
“By documenting Black firefighters’ experiences in the FDNY, Goldberg illustrates how big-city fire departments became key sites in the fight against racial and economic injustice in the twentieth century and were historically important in consolidating ideals of American national identity, including nativism, racism, and political corruption, but also courage, engaged citizenship, and benevolence.”—Clarence Lang, University of Kansas
